We know the major conferences are setting the policy, which means they get the lean when it comes to Selection Sunday. I’ve resigned myself to that fact, and so should you. Complaining is wasted emotion.
That said, I would like for you to keep your ears open all weekend and Monday for the double talk. I’ve reached the stage where this kind of stuff is entertaining to me, and you may as well do your best to enjoy it, too.
So my assignment is this: listen for the cliches and how they are applied to individual teams. It make for great fun. Here’s some things to look for:
If “Last 12″ doesn’t matter, listen for the number of times “the way they played in the conference tournament” is used. Let’s use Georgia Tech as the example. I’ve read many places and will be listening tomorrow for the “the win over North Carolina propelled them into the tournament, and the win over Maryland cemented it.”
That would be the #85 RPI North Carolina who went 4-12 in its last 16 games, and the Maryland team that lost, at home, to William & Mary.
And while we’re talking about the ACC and the Pugs, let’s put Virginia Tech and the Pugs next to each other. This one is the “who you play and where you play them” criteria:
RPI: VT (57), WM (58)
Record: VT (23-11), WM (21-10)
OOC record and SOS: VT 13-1 (#98); WM 7-3 (#13)
Road record: VT (6-5); WM (10-6)
Record, top 50: VT (3-4); WM (3-3)
Best wins: VT (home Clemson, home Wake); WM (at Maryland, at Wake, Richmond).
Best OOC wins: VT (Seton Hall-neutral, home Georgia); WM (see above).
And so that I’m not accused of picking on the ACC, let’s look at Minnesota here. The Gophers have been written off for three weeks. You’re telling me they are now in conversation due to one win over Michigan State who was without a star player?
Minnesota has an RPI of 73 and is 3-7 in road games. Just digest that and we’ll move on.
***
Next is the ye new “eyeball test.” If that is in effect, Wake Forest should be lucky to be chosen for a Wake Forest intrasquad scrimmage. They looked horrid and disinterested this past month.
Any of the SEC bubble teams are a bad choice. They define mediocre. If we’re going “body of work,” then Mississippi State’s losses to Rider and Western Kentucky have to come into play.
That’s it–I’m off to enjoy basketball. Just keep your ears open, laugh, and remember today’s reason why we have it better:
There’s no need to convince the world it isn’t seeing what it actually sees. We’re too smart for that.


March 13th, 2010 at 10:52 am
Great W&M/Tech comparison. Well done.
March 13th, 2010 at 12:03 pm
Nie post, thanks the information.
March 13th, 2010 at 1:31 pm
OOC record and SOS: VT 13-1 (#98); WM 7-3 (#13)
I was wondering where these SOS numbers came from. I’ve heard VT’s non-conference SOS is horrible, something like #340. Their total SOS, including ACC games might be something like #98, but no way W&M’s total SOS is #13, not if you’re including CAA games.
March 14th, 2010 at 10:33 am
Wow…it’s something when you compare the numbers. I wish W&M the best, but we know what the selection committee will do. The one year they had balls – picking Mason as a CAA at-large in 2006 – worked out. But, they haven’t made sense since then.
March 14th, 2010 at 10:49 am
I hate the selection committee… I love that North Carolina was a quality win, only in name, not in RPI or record wise, must be nice to play in a conference where if you get a win against a mediocre at best team, but it happens to have the name North Carolina attached to it, and automatically be assumed in the tournament. So wrong.
March 14th, 2010 at 11:29 am
[...] spotty RPI and so-so records gets major consideration for the NIT and even the big dance (see this http://www.caahoops.com/2010/03/we-know-how-this-goes/), a mid-major with the same, if not better credentials is left out of the picture. Did someone call [...]
March 14th, 2010 at 8:16 pm
YEAH!!! No Tech!!
March 14th, 2010 at 11:17 pm
[...] as Dick Vitale and Co. claim, then so did William & Mary. Michael Litos compared their resumes right here. Memo to Seth Greenburg: At least try to play somebody in November and December. Like VCU instead [...]
March 14th, 2010 at 11:46 pm
I can’t believe the CAA was shafted again, with WM having to go play at Chapel Hill…no way UNC is a higer seed than WM, and same could be said for UCONN/NE. Looking forward to two CAA wins, though!